Becoming a member of the LoveReading4Kids community is free.

No catches, no fine print just unconditional book loving for your children with their favourites saved to their own digital bookshelf.

New members get entered into our monthly draw to win £100 to spend in your local bookshop plus lots lots more...

Find out more

The Silent Stars Go By

Written by Sally Nicholls

Write A Review

The Silent Stars Go By Review

Books of the Month Family / Home Stories Featured Books for 13+ readers Featured Books for Young Adults Historical Fiction Romance / Relationship Stories Star Books

Secrets smoulder and romance promises to rekindle during the first festive season post-WWI

November 2020 Book of the Month

The Silent Stars Go By is a riveting read-in-one-sitting experience driven by compelling characters who leap off the page, not least the young woman at its heart, an unmarried secretarial student who’s forced to give up her baby during WWI. The novel is also underpinned by a superb sense of social history, with evocative details of post-war village life nestling within the bigger story, and - as might be expected of the author of Things a Bright Girl Can Do - it’s threaded with feminist themes.


It’s 1919, Christmas is on the horizon and two years have passed since nineteen-year-old Margot was forced to give up her baby for her parents to raise as their own. She was only fifteen when she and Harry fell madly in love ahead of him being called up. The magic of their time together is evoked in all its tingling passion, contrasting with Margot’s present-day torments. It hurts when little James calls her mother “Mummy”, and she doesn’t know how she can continue to keep James a secret from Harry, who’s returned to the village after recuperating on the Isle of Wight.


The flashbacks to Margot’s time on the maternity ward are particularly poignant and, of course, the reason she has to endure this unbearable situation is due to the fact that she lives in a world in which “the girl is the one whose honour is defiled or whatever rot they spout” whereas “the boy is just being a boy”. Coupled with that wider context, Margot’s vicar father is a man who “forgave drunks and tramps and fallen women and the men who tried to steal the lead from the church roof. But he couldn’t forgive her.” 


Realising that “things couldn’t go on like this,” Margot decides to confront her fears amidst the rare glamour of a ball on New Year’s Eve.

You can find more wintry & festive stories in our Best Books for Kids this Christmas collection.

Joanne Owen

Other Info

A message from the author Sally Nicholls;

As an author, I’ve always been fascinated by family dynamics, whether that’s step-families, siblings raising siblings or children being raised by grandparents. My own father was an illegitimate war-baby, born at the end of the second world war. My grandmother chose to keep him, but he grew up with the stigma of ‘bastard’ at his back. In our near-past, literally thousands of babies were hidden in large families. As a solution to a social problem, it was a neat one. But how could you possibly be a good mother to a child who thought you were his sister? 

Adoption was not legal in Britain until the 1926 Adoption Act. I was fascinated by the idea that Margot’s name would still be on her son’s birth certificate. How could you act in good faith to your child, your parents and your child’s father, knowing that that time-bomb was waiting somewhere in a study drawer? 

The Silent Stars Go By Synopsis

Seventeen-year-old Margot Allan was a respectable vicar's daughter and madly in love with her fiance Harry. But when Harry was reported Missing in Action from the Western Front, and Margot realised she was expecting his child, there was only one solution she and her family could think of in order to keep that respectability. She gave up James, her baby son, to be adopted by her parents and brought up as her younger brother.

Now two years later the whole family is gathering at the vicarage for Christmas. It's heartbreaking for Margot being so close to James but unable to tell him who he really is. But on top of that, Harry is also back in the village. Released from captivity in Germany and recuperated from illness, he's come home and wants answers.

Why has Margot seemingly broken off their engagement and not replied to his letters? Margot knows she owes him an explanation. But can she really tell him the truth about James?

The Silent Stars Go By Press Reviews

Sally Nicholls conjures another era with a miraculous lightness of touch that fills me with joy and envy. Her characters don't just leap off the page, they grab you by the collar, demand your sympathy and surprise you at every turn  -- Frances Hardinge

Gorgeous, poignant, unputdownable. A new Christmas classic  -- Hilary McKay

A gorgeous, festive treat of a story about family, lost loves and finding yourself again after tragedy. Sally Nicholls is brilliant: her writing reads like silk  -- Emma Carroll

A perfect family story - every character so well drawn - a story of love, loss and longing which tugs at your heart -- Keren David

Beautiful writing about a loving, troubled, real family - this is a book to settle down for the day with -- Holly Webb

If you loved this, you might like these...

Pride and Prejudice A Retelling
The Silent Stars Go By
The Heartstopper Yearbook
Gloves Off

All versions of this book

ISBN: 9781839131134
Publication date: 04/11/2021
Publisher: Andersen Press Ltd
Format: Paperback

ISBN: 9781783449903
Publication date: 05/11/2020
Publisher: Andersen Press Ltd
Format: Hardback

Book Information

ISBN: 9781783449903
Publication date: 5th November 2020
Author: Sally Nicholls
Publisher: Andersen Press Ltd
Format: Hardback
Pagination: 240 pages
Suitable for: 13+ readers, YA readers
Genres: Family / Home Stories, Historical Fiction, Romance / Relationship Stories
Recommendations: Books of the Month, Star Books
Collections: Girl Power - Inspiring and Informative Children's Books with a Feminist Message, Our favourite children's books of 2020,

About Sally Nicholls

I was born in Stockton-on-Tees, just after midnight, in a thunderstorm. My father died when I was two, and my brother Ian and I were brought up my mother. I always wanted to write - when people asked me what I wanted to be when I grew up, I used to say "I'm going to be a writer" - very definite. I've always loved reading, and I spent most of my childhood trying to make real life as much like a book as possible. My friends and I had a secret club like the Secret Seven, and when I was ...

More About Sally Nicholls

More Books By Sally Nicholls

Cover for The Button Book by Sally Nicholls
Cover for Season of Secrets by Sally Nicholls
Cover for Out of the Rubble by Sally Nicholls
View All Books By Sally Nicholls

Share this book